Blog

Should You Allow Your Child to Read Books That Are “Too Hard”?

Anne Hauth • August 1, 2023

“This book is too hard for you.” “This book isn’t at the right level.”

Have you ever said these things to a developing reader? You may have. As we all know, a book at the wrong level can easily cause a struggling reader to feel frustrated or incompetent—which may lead to just turning the pages and looking at pictures. Thus, it’s often appropriate to direct them toward easier reading material.


And yet, in some situations, a book that’s “too hard” is exactly the right choice. How do you know the difference?


An Education Week article entitled, Don’t Crush Reading Motivation,”* explores this topic. The article describes two types of reading: guided reading and self-selected reading. Guided reading is at the student’s instructional level, as determined by assessments. When students are involved in this type of reading, the teacher provides reading material at the correct level. This may mean steering students away from books that are too difficult. Guided reading has many benefits as students work to become fluent, but students’ choices are limited and sometimes don't match their interests.


The second type of reading, self-selected reading, involves the student choosing their own reading material from the library, classroom bookshelf, etc. In these situations, the student should be allowed to choose any book they are interested in—even a book that’s too hard. As the Education Week article explains:


“Through self-selected reading, students gain both a sense of independence and greater self-confidence. When their choices are validated—when the book is interesting and they enjoy it—they learn that they can make good decisions on their own. What's more, knowing that they can make wise reading choices can increase their motivation, a key component of independent reading. When a child is motivated to read a book, for whatever reason, this often compensates for any reading difficulties.


But what if a self-selected book is entirely too challenging for the student to read independently? In this situation, the student should be encouraged to read the book with a proficient reader—another student, a reading buddy from an older grade, or an available adult. Although the student’s independent reading time may be compromised while reading this book, there may be a bigger payoff in motivation and engagement—two very important components of independent reading. Students need books that motivate them to read and keep them engaged. When these elements are present, the student wants to read more often, and reading skills improve.


The Education Week article asserts that both guided reading and self-selected reading are important for developing readers, and we agree. In many ways, students working in One Minute Reader enjoy the benefits of both types of reading, without the drawbacks.


In the One Minute Reader program, students are placed into a level that’s slightly above instructional level. The level provides a challenge, but the strategy offers the support required for the student to succeed. Within this level, the student selects any story they want to read. All stories are high-interest nonfiction, and topics were carefully chosen to appeal to students of all ages. Because the student has the ability to self-select a story, engagement and motivation increase. One Minute Reader also provides audio support, so the student is still able to work independently. Motivation is enhanced by self-monitoring of progress, another key component of the program.


When students are working in One Minute Reader, they’re engaged with their self-selected reading material, and nobody needs to tell them it’s too hard.

Highlighted Posts

By Anne Hauth December 15, 2025
The other day, my son asked me why blizzards are hazardous. The most interesting part of his question was the way he said the word hazardous. He pronounced it incorrectly, with a long a: HAYzardous. This told me he’d never heard the word spoken aloud before. However, when I probed him on the word’s meaning, he knew it exactly. How? He came across the word in a book he was reading. He didn’t know what it meant, but he figured out the meaning using context clues. Sometimes an unknown word can stop a reader in their tracks, shutting down comprehension. But if the reader has the ability to figure the word out, comprehension can continue, and the new word becomes part of the reader’s vocabulary. According to the research, vocabulary and comprehension are strongly linked. Students with low vocabulary scores tend to have low comprehension, and vice versa. Students acquire vocabulary incidentally through exposure to words at home and at school—by listening and talking, by reading books with adults, and by reading widely on their own. Students, especially struggling readers, also benefit greatly if they are taught strategies for vocabulary acquisition. Vocabulary activities should aim to engage students in actively thinking about word meanings, the relationships among words, and how we can use words in different situations. Effective strategies for vocabulary practice include: Student-Friendly Definitions : The meaning of a new word should be explained to students at their level, rather than just providing a dictionary definition. Defining Words Within Context : The most effective time to introduce an unknown word’s meaning is often at the moment the reader meets the word in the text. Using Context Clues : Students should learn to infer the meaning of a word by looking closely at surrounding text. Sketching Words : For many students, it is easier to remember a word’s meaning by making a quick sketch that connects the word to something personally meaningful to the student. Applying Words : When students are challenged to apply new words to their own experiences, they have another opportunity to deeply process its meaning. Analyzing Word Parts : If students know the meanings of root words and affixes, they are more likely to understand a word containing these word parts. Semantic Mapping : Semantic maps help students develop connections among words—for example, by writing an example, a non-example, a synonym, and an antonym. Developing Word Consciousness : Students who are word conscious are aware of and interested in the words around them. Teachers can promote word consciousness by helping students use: Language categories: Students learn to make finer distinctions in their word choices if they understand the relationships among words, such as synonyms, antonyms, and homographs. Figurative language: The ability to use figures of speech is also a part of word-consciousness. The most common figures of speech are similes, metaphors, and idioms. We’ve strongly incorporated vocabulary development into One Minute Reader . If your child is using One Minute Reader, there are many ways for them to build vocabulary and increase comprehension: During the Cold Read step, they should click on unknown words to hear the words pronounced immediately. During the Read Alone step, they should click on highlighted vocabulary words to see and hear the definitions. They can also use our free Difficult Word List resource to sketch and record words they struggled with so that they may review them later. For targeted, game-based vocabulary practice, check out the Splat-O-Nym iPad app . With audio support and immediate feedback, Splat-O-Nym helps students learn pronunciation and enhance their vocabulary acquisition through fun activities. The app includes over 7,000 synonym questions, 1,000 antonym questions, and 600 meaning-from-context questions. After I answered my son’s question about blizzards, I high-fived him for figuring “HAYzardous” out as he read. At One Minute Reader, we're here to help you mitigate the hazards of low vocabulary and ensure your child has the tools they need to become a successful reader.
By Anne Hauth December 15, 2025
Regardless of where kids are on their reading journey, there are countless ways to incorporate reading into cozy days at home this winter. Here are some easy ideas for kids to try at home over winter break and beyond! Have kids think of the trusted friends, family members, or adults in their lives who can read, and encourage them to read aloud with these people as often as possible. Depending on their reading ability, they can simply listen to a book read aloud, or they can take turns reading and being read to. Have the kids fill out this Read-Aloud Log every time someone reads to them or every time they read to someone. You could offer a small reward for completing this activity every day of winter break (or every day during a predetermined time period). Reading aloud to their pets, stuffed animals, or even to themselves counts too! Set up reading challenges in which kids set goals and record their minutes spent reading or the number of books they read. Have kids color and decorate these winter-themed bookmarks to make reading even more fun. Encourage kids to borrow books from the library and have a big pile to choose from on cozy winter days. See this Cozy Wintertime Book List for book ideas. Refer to our 7 Ways to Create a Cozy Reading Environment document to create an ideal reading space. Lend or gift kids the first book in a series that’s likely to hook them. Sometimes all it takes is the right series to turn a reluctant reader into a bookworm! Incorporate reading time into other fun activities. For example, while making dinner or baking holiday treats, kids can read the recipes and write out the grocery lists. Create a snowflake book wall. Print out this Snowflake Wall Template , and have kids fill out a snowflake each time they finish a book. Then, have them tape the snowflake to the wall. Encourage kids to find ways to read while playing favorite games or while spending time on electronic devices. While playing games, have them read the game instructions aloud. While watching shows, have them turn on and read the subtitles. Have kids practice reading and writing while completing this fun Winter Scavenger Hunt . They’ll get some fresh air too! Refer to this Send Some Cheer printable for addresses to places where kids can send letters. Have them practice their writing skills and spread kindness by writing to kids in hospitals, senior citizens, refugee children, and more. Set up daily One Minute Reader time, and see literacy progress in just minutes! This research-proven, parent-trusted program is free for 7 days and just $8/month after that. Your kids will have so much fun beating their goals, they won't want to stop. Download the Splat-o-Nym vocabulary iPad app , which keeps kids entertained while boosting their vocabulary. Kids can try a free version of this game and purchase to get the full experience. Note that this app is only available for iPads, not smartphones or other devices. Add your own ideas to this list! Our hope is for all kids to experience the joy of reading this winter season and always.
Woman and child reading a book on a couch, promoting comprehension strategies.
By Anne Hauth December 12, 2025
Help your child build reading comprehension at home. Use easy, research-based strategies to boost reading fluency, vocabulary, and critical thinking.
Show More

Ready to see an improvement in your child's reading?

Sign up today and get seven days for FREE.

Sign up now!

One Minute Reader is just $8 per month after your free trial.